Tensions were high at the shared use pathway public comment meeting
Tensions were high during the public comment period for the Northern Scenic Greenway shared-used path on Tuesday, Nov. 17. One person was asked to leave for yelling over speakers and getting into an argument, and many were shouting into the microphone. There were over 100 people in attendance from all over the South Coast.
Amy Archer from Pare Corporations, who was hired by the Southcoast Bikeway Alliance to design the path, presented the initial findings.
The path would go through Westport, Dartmouth and New Bedford.
Pare looked at crash data on the planned path from the past three years; Dartmouth had a total of 54 crashes that caused 24 injuries and one fatality. A majority of the crashes, 38, were single vehicle crashes from swerving and speeding.
They presented the dimensions of each section of the 9.8 mile planned path through Dartmouth, considering movable and unmovable features. The widest area was 60’ and the thinnest area was a 0.09 mile path at 33’ width due to a church.
They are considering an alternative path through a private solar farm to widen this section, and are currently in talks with the owner.
Features such as shrubbery and telephone poles could be moved to widen the path, while features like stone walls and wells cannot and will not be touched.
There are six options for the path they are considering:
-
A single bike lane with a painted line separating it from the road
-
A thin path on one side with a painted barrier
-
A two-lane pathway with a painted barrier
-
A two-lane pathway with a curb barrier
-
A two-lane pathway that is separated from the road with a small median
-
A completely separate pathway
The path would include stops at beloved locations in Dartmouth, such as Cornell Pond Park, Running Brook Vineyard, Turner Pond and some of the Dartmouth Natural Resource Trust parks. There would also be rest spots with over a 5% running grade, as per ADA restrictions.
After presenting the options, Archer opened the floor to public comment. Public comment lasted around two hours with almost 40 speakers, with the overwhelming sentiment being against the bike path.
The most cited reason for not wanting a bike or shared use path is the safety of Old Fall River Road. During the meeting, many residents brought up accidents from speeding on the curves. Many had stories of cars crashing in their driveways.
“Where does this madness stop?” asked Kathy Normore. “We are not safe now.”
The roads were widened in 2019 to prevent crashes, according to Normore. Pare stated that by making the roads more narrow, studies have shown that drivers drive slower.
One woman from Westport cited having a motorcycle crash on her lawn, and it took 20 minutes for the police to arrive and 35 for an ambulance.
Another resident from Old Fall River Road cited having his fence driven through, and boulders placed as a fence forced out of the ground overnight from crashes.
Almost every person concerned about the safety of the road mentioned the speed at which drivers drive down Old Fall River Road. Many drivers go over the speed limit, especially when maps reroute people onto Old Fall River Road to avoid highway traffic.
A majority of those worried about safety quoted feeling unsafe in their own yards and walking on the road as it is right now. Some asked if there would be increased lighting and other safety precautions taken to ensure safety.
Many were angry that the project is happening regardless of citizen protest. One man compared the government to “a tick on a dog” for the fact that projects take so long they are outdated once they’re finished.
“This is still the United States of America, and what I’ve seen here is socialism,” said a resident from New Plainville Road. Many agreed with this sentiment, as this received cheers and claps, and others described this as socialism.
Another stated, “To spend millions of dollars … for the minority, not the majority.”
One more stated, “This is a political and an enforcement and a criteria issue.”
Others were concerned about preserving the scenic nature of Old Fall River Road. Some mentioned the historic trees and the fact the road is a Scenic Road. Chair of the Pathways Committee William Trimble suggested that they include these historic trees on the path.
One of the other more popular worries is that the bike path will not be used, or used for bad reasons. Some feel that bikers will not travel for the path, and it won’t bring the business that members of the Bikeway Alliance and Pathways Committee feel it will. There was also concern that this will act as a connector for drug dealing and homeless encampments.
There were some supporters of the bike path in attendance, arguing that if the path is kept clean then bikers will come and use it. They added that by visiting the town, it would encourage the local economy. These were dubbed the “Spandex Warriors" by one person in the audience and on Facebook.
Pare is going to take the criticism into consideration when doing further research into the land and creating an initial design. They hope to have an alternative development and analysis by February, when the next public meeting will be held.
For those who were unable to attend the public comment period, the alliance is accepting comments at scba.nsg@gmail.com.












